Sales of old-fashioned, newly hip vinyl records keep climbing. More and more current bands - and their young fans - want new music released on the same vinyl format their parents grew up listening to.
But why? Sure, 12-inch records look cooler than puny CDs. But do they actually sound better? Jack White of the White Stripes thinks so: He’s already told fans to buy the new album by his other band, the Raconteurs, on record if they want to hear it at its best.
Of course, this contradicts what record companies said when they introduced the “perfect sound forever” of the CD in the mid-’80s. Were they mistaken? Can a scratchy slab of vinyl actually out-perform the millions of ones and zeros encoded on compact discs?
Last week, the Herald attempted to find out. With a stack of LPs and CDs - and local musicians Rick Berlin, Jussi Gamache (also known as Liz Enthusiasm from Freezepop) and TAB the Band’s guitarist Tony Perry and drummer Ben Tileston - we crashed Harvard Square’s Audio Lab.
Clustered around a store stereo system that costs as much as a Cadillac (OK, a gently used Cadillac) we gave our panel a blind taste test by spinning the same song back-to-back on both formats. Could they tell the difference between vinyl and CD? And if so, what did they prefer and why?
It seemed simple enough. But as eight ears and a dozen spins proved, there is no better or worse, only different - at least if you’re blasting Led Zeppelin on high end high-fi.
In honor of Jack White and his gig with the Raconteurs Tuesday night at the Bank of America Pavilion, we began with the title track of their new album, “Consolers of the Lonely.” The contrast between the two formats was immediately identifiable: Even a virgin vinyl copy of “Consolers” had a hiss that was a dead giveaway to everyone on the panel.
Hiss aside, both Berlin and the guys from TAB mentioned the LP version’s “warmer feel” and richer low end. It was a theme that followed the group through much of the session: the fuzzy warmth, full low-end and hiss of vinyl vs. cleaner, clearer, crisper CD digital sound.
Listening to Stevie Wonder’s “Superstition” in both formats, Tileston zeroed in on the percussion.
“On the LP, the snare has a low end kick to it,” the rock drummer noted. “The kick drum sits in the right frequency. The cymbals have a much clearer mix.”
For Gamache, who fronts an electro-pop band, the scratches and pops “sort of worked well with the song. It sounded too clean on CD,” she said, summing up the panel’s thoughts.
But the group split on Led Zeppelin’s “Immigrant Song.” Even a fresh copy of the LP didn’t have the brightness and dynamic flavor of the CD.
“It’s way sharper than the LP,” said Berlin. “There’s a distinct separation (between instruments). The vocals are more discernable.”
Which format actually sounds better? Sorry, Mr. White. There’s no definitive answer.
“It really depends on the song,” said Perry. “Some songs could sound better on one format, but weren’t mastered right. Some songs today are recorded with everything just pulled back from the red line of distortion so it can never sound right with the limitations of the vinyl groove. I tend to think older stuff sounds better on vinyl and newer stuff sounds better on CD. But not always.”
Basically, there are dozens of confounding variables, taste being one of the biggest. If you’re looking for a guiding piece of LP vs. CD wisdom, Audio Lab manager Mike Volpe may have come closest to delineating the differences between the two formats.